Read › Upadeshasahasri ›

Upadeshasahasri 18.131

18.131 Shankaracharya

आत्मनो ग्रहणे चापि त्रयाणामिह संभवात् । आत्मन्यासक्तकर्तृत्वं न स्यात्करणकर्मणोः ॥

ātmano grahaṇe cāpi trayāṇāmiha saṃbhavāt | ātmanyāsaktakartṛtvaṃ na syātkaraṇakarmaṇoḥ ||

Also, if the Self were grasped [in this way], since all three would arise here, agency would be fixed on the Self; [the Self] could not [also] be instrument and object.

और यदि आत्मा का [इस प्रकार] ग्रहण हो, तो तीनों के यहाँ होने से कर्तृत्व आत्मा पर टिकेगा; [आत्मा] करण और कर्म नहीं हो सकती।

Meaning today and contextआज के लिए अर्थ और संदर्भ

Part of a technical argument: the one who knows cannot at the same time be the thing it knows.

एक तकनीकी तर्क का अंश: जानने वाला उसी समय वह वस्तु नहीं हो सकता जिसे वह जानता है।

Shankaracharya adds a further objection to the Mimamsaka view: if the Self were grasped in cognition, it would have to be agent, instrument and object at once, but agency attached to the Self excludes its also being instrument and object.

Read in context Ask Antah Saarthi